Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.
To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser.
A. Bernabé et al. (eds), Redefining Dionysos, Berlin and New York: de Gruyter, 2013, 4-22. Note that the article has been reprinted and updated in my The World of Greek Religion and Mythology (Tuebingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2019) 29-45
History of Religions
On the Nature of the Gods: Methodological Suggestions for the study of Greek Divinities2018 •
The paper argues for a novel method for understanding Greek gods, building on the approach of J.-P. Vernant, but adding a new dimension to it. Vernant attempted to read the Greek pantheon as a system of classification and to see the multifarious attributes and functions of the gods as parts of a meaningful structure, in this way allowing modern readers to understand the gods instead of seeing them an incongruous assemblage of various historically contingent traits. While considering this type of approach as fruitful, I argue that Vernant has overstressed the systematic side of the gods, downplaying their anomalous and chaotic aspects – not in the sense of their heterogeneous qualities that arise as a result of contingent historical development (as runs the usual criticism by historians of Greek religion) but much more importantly in the sense of their transgressive and antistructural features which are an integral part of their personalities. These result from the fact that while the gods help to establish and guard various ideal categories of the human world, they do so from without and are not constrained by them themselves. In this way the gods are able to support the system while balancing out some of its inevitable limitations, mediating its internal contradictions and introducing flexibility into its static categories. I subsequently draw methodological consequences from this general conception. When studying a god I suggest to pay attention to the boundaries this god both protects and transcends, i.e. to focus on both the normative and the transgressive of the god in question, on the ability to unite various conflicting principles in the god’s personality, and on the transitions the god allows his or her worshippers to make. In this way I hope to convey to the modern reader not just the meaningfulness of the gods but also their indispensability for the correct functioning of the Greek cultural system.
Julia Kindt, Rethinking Greek Religion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2013. Pp. xiii + 235. ISBN 978-0-521-12773-8 (paperback). Julia Kindt's point of departure is the study of Greek religion as an interpretive rather than just a descriptive practice. Recognizing the importance of the focus of the past decades on the institutional and official aspects of Greek religion, Kindt follows those who since the 1990s have critically asked what the concept of polis religion omits and does not see. Thus, her aim is to explore Greek religion " beyond the polis " , focusing on aspects below the polis level concerning belief and personal experience, and above the polis level, concerning ethnic identity. Common for these aspects is that they were for a long time considered impossible to discuss on a scientifically sound level. Chapter 1 looks at the model of polis religion, developed in the vein of Durkheim's 1 concept of religion as linked to the collective and social. One advantage of the model is that it is historical and made it possible for the study of Greek religion to break out of the structuralist, a-historical perspective. Whereas the model has helped highlighting many aspects of Greek religion that had previously been hidden, it is now time to look at those aspects left out or overseen by it. These are both personal and private aspects, such as the consultation of oracles, and ethnic aspects, such as religious identity on a larger scale than the level of the polis. Whereas polis religion is indeed to be seen as crucial for Greek religion, it makes up only part of a whole. Yet, the solution is not to set a division between polis religion on the one hand and " the rest " on the other hand; instead, Kindt sees progress in those studies that focus on the relationship between the city and the " unauthorized " or local religious beliefs and practices (p.24). The model of polis religion has the advantage of providing a structure to the study of Greek religion which as such lacks structure in the form of, e.g., creed. Yet, the danger for this model, as for any model, is that deviants from the model may be seen as exceptions or deviations from a more or less homogeneous picture, rather than extensions of the model (p.35). Chapter 2 deals with the " religious gaze " which is discussed on the basis of the variety of Greek cult statues and divine representations, as they come in iconic and an-iconic types, from precious and elaborate chryselephantine statues to crude xoana made of wood or metal. The concrete source material is the story of Parmeniscus who learns to laugh again, as his expectations of seeing the statue of Leto in an anthropomorphic form are disappointed because her statue at Delos was in fact a primitive xoana. The theoretical material making up the basis for the discussion is on the one hand Elsner's 2 definition of the religious gaze as not being concerned with aesthetics but oriented towards the ritual function of material artefacts, such as cult statues (p.40). On the other hand it is Guthrie's 3 cognitive theory of religion according to which humans (and primates) have a natural inclination for making sense of unknown things, sounds, and phenomena. Elsner points to the important
J.N. Bremmer and A. Erskine (eds), The Gods of Ancient Greece, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2010, 1-18 (http://www.euppublishing.com/book/9780748683222?template=toc&), but note that this article has been updated and reprinted in my The World of Greek Religion and Mythology (2019)
The Greek Gods in the Twentieth CenturyThis is the introduction to the first modern study of the gods of the ancient Greeks in antiquity. The contents of the book are: List of illustrations; Notes on Contributors; Abbreviations; Preface; Introduction: The Greek Gods in the Twentieth Century, Jan N. Bremmer; 1. What is a Greek God?, Albert Henrichs; Systematic Aspects: 2. Canonizing the Pantheon: the Dodekatheon in Greek Religion and its Origins, Ian Rutherford; 3. Gods in Greek Inscriptions: Some Methodological Questions, Fritz Graf; 4. Metamorphoses of Gods into Animals and Humans, Richard Buxton; 5. Sacrificing to the Gods: Ancient Evidence and Modern Interpretations, Stella Georgoudi; 6. Getting in Contact: Concepts of Human/Divine Encounter in Classical Greek Art, Anja Klöckner; 7. New Statues for Old Gods, Kenneth Lapatin; Individual Divinities and Heroes: 8. Zeus at Olympia, Judith M. Barringer; 9. Zeus in Aeschylus: the Factor of Monetisation, Richard Seaford; 10. Hephaistos Sweats or How to Construct an Ambivalent God, Jan N. Bremmer; 11. Transforming Artemis - From the Goddess of the Outdoors to City-Goddess, Ivana Petrovic; 12. Herakles between Gods and Heroes, Emma Stafford; 13. Identities of Gods and Heroes: Athenian Garden Sanctuaries and Gendered Rites of Passage, Claude Calame; Diachronic Aspects: 14. Early Greek Theology: God as Nature and Natural Gods, Simon Trépanier; 15. Gods in Early Greek Historiography, Robert L. Fowler; 16. Gods in Apulia, Tom H. Carpenter; 17. Lucian's Gods: Lucian's Understanding of the Divine, Matthew W. Dickie; 18. The Gods in the Greek Novel, Ken Dowden; 19. Reading Pausanias: Cults of the Gods and Representation of the Divine, Vinciane Pirenne-Delforge; 20. Kronos and the Titans as Powerful Ancestors: A Case Study of the Greek Gods in Later Magical Spells, Christopher A. Faraone; 21. Homo fictor deorum est: Envisioning the Divine in Late Antique Divinatory Spells, Sarah Iles Johnston; 22. The Gods in Later Orphism, Alberto Bernabé; 23. Christian Apologists and Greek Gods, Lautaro Roig Lanzillotta; 24. The Materiality of God's Image: Olympian Zeus and Ancient Christology, Christoph Auffarth; Historiography: 25. The Greek Gods in Late Nineteenth- and Early Twentieth-Century German and British Scholarship, Michael Konaris; Epilogue, Andrew Erskine; Index of names, subjects and important passages.
Arctos. Acta Philologica Fennica
Arctos 55 (2021) Petra Pakkanen book review of Natur – Mythos – Religion im Antiken Griechenland / Nature – Myth – Religion in Ancient Greece. Herausgegeben von Tanja Susanne Scheer. Postdamer altertumswissenschaftliche Beiträge 67. Franz Steiner Verlag, Stuttgart 2019.2021 •
The World of Greek Religion and Mythology = Collected Essays II, published by Mohr Siebeck: https://www.mohrsiebeck.com/en/book/the-world-of-greek-religion-and-mythology-9783161544514?no_cache=1&tx_sgpublisher_pi1%5Bbacklink%5D=1
The World of Greek Religion and Mythology2019 •
From the publisher: In this wide-ranging work on Greek religion and mythology, Jan N. Bremmer brings together his stimulating and innovative articles, which have all been updated and revised where necessary. In three thematic sections, he analyses central aspects of Greek religion, beginning with the gods and heroes and paying special attention to the unity of the divine nature and the emergence of the category 'hero'. The second section begins with a discussion of the nature of polis religion, continues with various facets, such as seers, secrecy and the soul, and concludes with the influence of the Ancient Near East. The third section studies human sacrifice and offers the most recent analysis of the ideal animal sacrifice, combining literature, epigraphy, iconography, and zooarchaeology. Regarding human sacrifice, it concentrates on the famous cases of Iphigeneia and the werewolves of Mount Lykaion. The fourth and final section investigates key elements of Greek mythology, such as the definition of myth and its relationship to ritual, and ends with a brief history of the study of Greek mythology. The multi-disciplinary approach and rich footnotes make this work a must for anybody interested in Greek religion and mythology.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.
R. von Haehling (ed.), Griechische Mythologie und Frühchristentum, Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 2005, 21-43. Note that this article has been updated and revised in my The World of Greek Religion and Mythology (Tubingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2019) 427-445
Myth and Ritual in Ancient Greece: Observations on a Difficult RelationshipKeynote paper 10th London Ancient Science Conference, Institute of Classical Studies, University College London, Inst
Revisiting the religion of the early Greek philosophers.pdf2016 •
R. Schlesier (ed.), A Different God? Dionysos and Ancient Polytheism (Berlin 2011) 23-46
HEIS DIONUSOS! - ONE DIONYSOS? A POLYTHEISTIC PERSPECTIVEClassical Bulletin
Review of A. Tripolitis, Religions of the Hellenistic-Roman Age W.B. Eerdemans, Grand Rapids, Mich, 2002. CB 79.2 (2004), 326-330.2004 •
The Classical Review 64
Review: M.Haysom and J.Wallensten, eds., Current Approaches to Religion in Ancient Greece. Stockholm, 20112014 •
Folklore 76: 187–192
The Greek Roots of Myth Criticism – Review of Michael Herren, The Anatomy of Myth, Oxford, 20172019 •
2009 •
Opuscula 5, 190-192
Review by Gunnel Ekroth of "Aspects of Ancient Greek Cult: Context, Ritual, Iconography," edited by Tae Jensen, J., G. Hinge, P. Schultz and B. Wicckiser2012 •
2021 •
Bryn Mawr Classical Review
Review of A. Gregory, The Presocratics and the Supernatural: Magic, Philosophy and Science in Early Greece, London 2013, in BMCR 2014.11.222014 •
New Aspects of Religion in Ancient Athens
New Aspects of Religion in Ancient Athens2016 •
JOURNAL OF HELLENIC RELIGION
JOURNAL OF HELLENIC RELIGION Studies on ancient Greek religion and theology Volume 14 (2021) - Front Matter - Éditions Méduse d'Or2021 •
Mythos. Rivista di Storia delle Religioni
Comparing words, myths, and rituals. Alfred Loisy, Franz Cumont and the case of "Gaionas le deipnokritès"2013 •
Open Philosophy, De Gruyter
Rethinking Dionysus and Apollo: Redrawing Today's Philosophical Chessboard [2022] / Scholarly Article2022 •
The Classical Review (New Series)
Evangeliou Hellenic Philosophy: Origin and Character. Pp. x+ 231. Aldershot and Burlington, VT: Ashgate, 2006. Cased,£ 55, US $99.95. ISBN: 978-0-7546-5847-4.2008 •
2010 •
Beyond the Polis
Invention of Tradition in Cult and Myth at Eleusis2019 •